logo-harmony-strap-1

Addressing Loneliness & Housing Needs for Older & Younger Residents

As more people live longer, the issues of loneliness and isolation are becoming increasingly prevalent, particularly among older adults. Loneliness has been linked to a range of serious health problems, including dementia, heart disease, and depression. Studies have shown that loneliness is as harmful to health as smoking 15 cigarettes a day, and it significantly increases the risk of early death. Specifically, individuals experiencing loneliness are 29% more likely to die prematurely (Holt-Lunstad, 2010; Valtorta et al, 2016). These issues are compounded by the fact that many older adults live in rural areas where access to social services and care is often limited.

The Role of Intergenerational Living

Intergenerational living is one solution to combat loneliness and promote social cohesion. This living arrangement allows people of all ages to reside in the same communities and often within the same housing developments, fostering relationships across generations. By having both younger and older residents living side by side, intergenerational housing promotes social interaction, mutual support, and reduces feelings of isolation. For older residents, it provides a sense of security, knowing they have a support system of neighbours who are readily available for companionship or assistance. For younger residents, particularly those in care-related fields, it offers affordable housing in areas where housing costs might otherwise be prohibitive.

Harmony’s Purpose-Built Homes: A Community Focussed Solution

The Harmony initiative, in tandem with the Horizon model, is a practical response to these challenges, offering purpose-built homes designed specifically for people over the age of 55. These homes provide affordable accommodation for older adults, helping them to remain in their communities and maintain their independence. By enabling elderly residents to age in place, the scheme not only addresses housing needs but also combats social isolation by ensuring that older people have regular interactions with their neighbours.

One key feature of the Harmony scheme is the inclusion of younger residents, particularly those working or training in the care sector. Given that many care workers are paid low wages, they often struggle to afford housing in rural areas where rents can be high and job opportunities limited. Harmony addresses this challenge by offering social rent homes to younger people who have experience in care or are undergoing training in this field. In return for their tenancy at an affordable rate, these younger residents commit to being ‘good neighbours’ and providing an agreed number of hours per month of companionship and support to the older residents. This exchange not only helps reduce isolation but also creates a positive and supportive community where everyone can benefit from the experience of living alongside others.

Assistive Technology and Supportive Living

In addition to fostering intergenerational relationships, Harmony homes are equipped with assistive technologies designed to enhance the quality of life for older residents. These technologies can include features like smart home systems that monitor health and safety, emergency alert systems, and other devices that support independent living. The goal is to provide a safe, supportive environment where elderly tenants feel empowered to live independently while knowing that help is available when needed. The inclusion of younger residents who are trained or training in care further enriches the community, ensuring that there is always someone nearby who understands the needs of the older population and can provide practical or emotional support.

Conclusion

Harmony provides an innovative solution to the dual challenges of elderly isolation and affordable housing in rural communities. By integrating intergenerational living with purpose-built homes and support systems, it creates communities that are socially connected, inclusive, and resilient. Through this approach, Harmony helps reduce reliance on external care services, supports local care workers by offering affordable housing, and promotes positive relationships between generations - ultimately creating healthier, happier, and more sustainable communities.

Benefits of the Harmony Approach

  • Combats Loneliness and Isolation: The Harmony initiative directly addresses the growing problem of loneliness among older adults, particularly in rural communities. By fostering intergenerational living, it creates opportunities for older residents to form meaningful connections with younger people, reducing feelings of isolation and improving mental health and wellbeing.
  • Promotes Community Cohesion: Harmony promotes stronger, more integrated communities by encouraging interaction and mutual support between different age groups. Older residents benefit from having younger neighbours who can offer assistance, while younger residents gain valuable experience in the care sector, making the entire community more supportive and interconnected.
  • Affordable Housing for Young Care Workers: One of the key challenges in rural areas is the high cost of housing, especially for care workers who are often paid low wages. Harmony provides affordable accommodation for younger people working or training in the care sector, which helps reduce housing stress for key workers and supports the provision of care services within the community.
  • Assistive Technology for Ageing Residents: The homes are equipped with assistive technologies that enhance the independence of older residents, improving their quality of life and enabling them to live safely and comfortably in their homes for longer. This also helps reduce the pressure on formal care services and the social care system.
  • Mutual Benefit: The model offers benefits to both older and younger residents. Older tenants receive regular visits and support from younger neighbours, while younger residents gain affordable housing in a community setting, as well as the chance to contribute positively to the wellbeing of their elderly neighbours.

Challenges

  • Sustainability and Funding: The success of the Harmony model depends on long-term funding and support. Ensuring that enough resources are available to maintain and expand the scheme could be a challenge, especially in areas where budgets for social housing and care services are already stretched.
  • Potential for Dependency on Volunteers: While the system encourages younger tenants to provide regular support for older neighbours, this reliance on a volunteer-like workforce (i.e., care workers volunteering in exchange for affordable rent) could be unsustainable in the long run. If younger residents are unable or unwilling to provide the agreed-upon support, it could leave elderly tenants without adequate assistance.
  • Limited Availability of Suitable Properties: There may be challenges in creating enough Harmony homes to meet the demand for affordable housing and the specific needs of elderly residents. The availability of suitable land, particularly in rural areas, may limit the scale of the initiative. This may prevent it from reaching enough people to have a meaningful impact on housing and isolation issues in some communities.
  • Over-reliance on Young Care Workers: The model depends on the presence of young care workers living in the community. While this can provide vital support, it also assumes that there will always be enough younger people willing to take part in the scheme, which may not be the case. Furthermore, if the housing becomes more desirable to other young people who are not working in the care sector, the model may become less effective in providing essential support for elderly residents.
  • Social Rent Levels vs. Financial Sustainability: While the social rent model helps ensure affordability, charging below-market rates may not provide enough financial return for housing providers to cover maintenance costs, especially with the added expenses of assistive technologies and ongoing support for residents. This could create financial sustainability challenges for the initiative if not carefully managed.
  • Limited Choice for Younger Tenants: For younger tenants, particularly those working in care, living in a shared, intergenerational environment may not always appeal. While some may appreciate the community model, others may find it challenging to live alongside older generations, potentially leading to tension or dissatisfaction if their needs and lifestyles don’t align.

Summary

In summary, the positives of the Harmony model lie in its potential to address pressing social issues like loneliness and isolation, support affordable housing for key workers, and integrate technology and care into a sustainable, supportive community. However, the negatives highlight challenges such as reliance on volunteers, financial sustainability, and ensuring that the scheme meets the needs of all parties involved without placing undue strain on either older or younger residents. Balancing these benefits and challenges will be key to the success of the initiative.